
Roxy Hotel New York
Best for nightlife and music-focused stays—live jazz, a subterranean club, and DJ nights keep the energy late.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Roxy Hotel New York is a downtown, music-forward boutique hotel for travelers who want live entertainment, late-night jazz, and a SoHo/Tribeca base. The Carlyle, A Rosewood Hotel is a classic 5-star Upper East Side property for guests who want old‑New‑York service, formal dining, and cultural proximity to Central Park and the Met.
Updated · about 6.0 km apart

Best for nightlife and music-focused stays—live jazz, a subterranean club, and DJ nights keep the energy late.

Best for a traditional luxury stay near Central Park—formal bars, a full-service spa, and classic Upper East Side service.
When Roxy Hotel New York wins: choose Roxy if you want an energetic downtown scene with nightly live music, a cinema, and venues that double as event spaces—good for younger travelers, couples, and anyone prioritizing nightlife and cultural programming.
When The Carlyle, A Rosewood Hotel wins: pick The Carlyle if you want a quiet, formal luxury experience on the Upper East Side close to Central Park and the city’s major museums, with a full-service spa and a storied bar (Bemelman's) for classic cocktails.
Bottom line: Both hotels have strong New York identities but different personalities—Roxy delivers downtown nightlife and creative programming; The Carlyle delivers traditional, society‑style luxury and museum‑district convenience.
| Category | Roxy Hotel New York | The Carlyle, A Rosewood Hotel |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Downtown, music-led boutique with nightlife and event spaces | Formal, old‑New‑York 5‑star hotel with society‑hotel traditions |
| Location | Border of SoHo and TriBeCa (2 Avenue of the Americas) | Upper East Side, near Central Park (35 E 76th St) |
| Size (guest rooms) | 201 guest rooms across 8 floors | 188 guestrooms |
| Age / style | Rebranded Tribeca property with contemporary, entertainment-focused design | Legendary, Art Deco–period society hotel with classic interiors |
| Pools | No on-site swimming pool | |
| Restaurants & bars | Roxy Bar, The Django (jazz club), The Oyster Bar, Roxy Café | Two restaurants/cafes and Bemelman's Bar; 24-hour room service available |
| Spa / wellness | No on-site spa; on-site hair/beauty salon; 24-hour fitness center | Full-service spa and health club plus fitness facilities |
| Known for | Live entertainment, arthouse cinema, seasonal loaner bicycles, pet-friendly policy | Cultural cachet, Bemelman's Bar, proximity to Central Park and the Met |
| Family / age policy | All ages welcome; minimum check-in age 21 for registering adult | All ages welcome (not adults-only per supplier listing) |
| Typical guest | Nightlife-seeking couples, music fans, creatives and event groups | Museum-goers, leisure travelers seeking classic luxury, business guests who prefer traditional service |
Roxy sits on the border of SoHo and TriBeCa, well placed for downtown exploration.
Choose Roxy for downtown access, easy subway connections, and a lively neighborhood.
The Carlyle is on the Upper East Side a short walk from Central Park and the city’s museum mile.
Choose The Carlyle to stay near Central Park and the major Upper East Side museums.
Roxy provides 201 rooms with a contemporary downtown aesthetic and suites aimed at entertainment-minded stays.
Roxy’s rooms are geared to a nightlife-and-entertainment audience with practical in-room amenities.
The Carlyle offers 188 guestrooms ranging from Superior Rooms to multiple suite categories and two‑bedroom suites.
The Carlyle focuses on traditional luxury guestrooms and a larger suite selection for classic stays.
Roxy’s food and drink options pair all‑day dining with a strong live‑music program.
Roxy is for guests who want nightly entertainment with their dining and late operating hours.
The Carlyle’s outlets lean formal and historically rooted, with notable bars and room service.
The Carlyle suits guests preferring classic cocktail bars and restaurant formality near museum attractions.
Roxy’s defining features are its entertainment spaces and event venues.
Book Roxy when you want in-house entertainment or a flexible event venue with a downtown attitude.
The Carlyle’s signature features are its discreet luxury services and classic bars.
The Carlyle is better if a refined, museum‑adjacent, service-driven stay is important.
Roxy mixes a 24‑hour fitness center with active nightlife and entertainment programming.
Roxy pairs a basic but accessible gym with strong nightlife and external spa partnerships.
The Carlyle emphasizes spa services and a quieter nighttime environment.
Choose The Carlyle for on-site spa treatments and a subdued evening atmosphere.

Roxy — nightly jazz at The Django, live sets at Roxy Bar, and DJ programming make this the pick for after‑dark culture.

The Carlyle — proximity to Central Park and the Met plus a full‑service spa and formal bars suit museum‑minded luxury travelers.

Roxy — unusually generous pet policy that welcomes any number/size of pets with on-site amenities and nearby dog‑park access.

The Carlyle — supplier listing includes a full‑service spa and health club for in‑house wellness services.
The Carlyle is closer to Central Park and the Metropolitan Museum of Art; it’s a short walk to the museum district.
Roxy Hotel New York has more on‑site nightlife, including The Django jazz club, Roxy Bar with live music and DJs, and late‑night programming.
No — neither Roxy Hotel New York nor The Carlyle lists an on‑site swimming pool in their supplier details.
The Carlyle provides a full‑service spa on site; Roxy does not have an on‑site spa but partners with nearby spa facilities.
Explore how Roxy Hotel New York stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·