
Roxy Hotel New York
Best for nights out and on-site entertainment — live jazz, DJs, and an arthouse cinema every week.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Roxy Hotel New York is a lively, entertainment-forward boutique hotel on the SoHo/Tribeca border with live jazz, an arthouse cinema, and multiple nightlife venues — read this if you want evenings filled with music and a downtown vibe. The New York EDITION is a design-forward 5-star lifestyle hotel steps from Madison Square Park — read this if you prefer polished design, a quieter Midtown location, and full-service hotel amenities.
Updated · about 1.8 km apart

Best for nights out and on-site entertainment — live jazz, DJs, and an arthouse cinema every week.

Best for a refined, design-forward Midtown stay with classic EDITION dining and meeting facilities.
When Roxy Hotel New York wins: pick the Roxy if you want late-night live music, a subterranean jazz club (The Django), an independent cinema, and a buzzy downtown neighborhood with pet-friendly policies.
When The New York EDITION wins: choose The New York EDITION if you want a five-star, design-forward hotel near Madison Square Park with more traditional luxury services (spa treatment rooms, more meeting space, two bars/lounges) and a quieter Midtown setting.
Bottom line: both hotels have strong style; pick Roxy for nightlife, entertainment, and downtown character, or The New York EDITION for a polished luxury base near Flatiron and Madison Square Park.
| Category | Roxy Hotel New York | The New York EDITION |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Downtown boutique focused on nightlife, live music, cinema and relaxed American dining. | Design-forward 5-star lifestyle hotel with refined public spaces and classic EDITION service. |
| Location | Border of SoHo and TriBeCa (2 Avenue of the Americas). Good for downtown walking and subway access. | Steps from Madison Square Park (5 Madison Avenue). Better for Flatiron/NoMad/5th Avenue. |
| Size (rooms) | 201 rooms across 8 floors. | 271 rooms. |
| Ages / policy | All ages welcome; minimum check-in age 21. | All ages welcome (adults-only: false). |
| Pools | No swimming pool on site (has a free 9-foot billiards table in the lobby). | Not published |
| Restaurants & bars | Multiple on-site venues: Roxy Bar, The Django (jazz club), The Oyster Bar, Roxy Café. | One main restaurant (The Clocktower) and 2 bars/lounges; 24-hour room service available. |
| Spa / wellness | No full spa on-site; on-site hair/beauty salon and partnership with nearby thermal baths. | Spa treatment room(s) and on-site spa services available. |
| Known for | Live entertainment, arthouse cinema, evening music venues and pet-friendly policies. | Design-forward EDITION style, proximity to Madison Square Park, meeting/conference space. |
| Meetings & events | Extensive event footprint (approx. 12,396 sq ft across multiple unique venues, rooftop terrace, cinema and jazz club for events). | Conference space of 2,100 sq ft with 5 meeting rooms and banquet/meeting facilities. |
| Connectivity & fees | Complimentary 20MB Wi‑Fi (premium paid upgrade); mandatory amenity fee of $39.95 + tax per night; valet parking available. | Complimentary WiFi; destination fee applies (listed as USD 51.64 per night in supplier listing); valet parking (surcharge). |
Roxy sits on the border of SoHo and TriBeCa at 2 Avenue of the Americas, convenient for downtown sightseeing and nightlife.
Best if you plan to spend evenings downtown and want easy access to Tribeca/SoHo neighborhoods.
The New York EDITION at 5 Madison Avenue is a Midtown location centered on Madison Square Park and Flatiron/NoMad attractions.
Best if you prefer Midtown/Flatiron access and a quieter base near Madison Square Park.
Roxy offers 201 rooms and suites across eight floors with a downtown boutique mix.
Chooses a variety of boutique room types with locally focused in-room touches and entertainment-focused fees.
The New York EDITION offers 271 air-conditioned rooms with Smart TVs and minibars.
Offers a full luxury room lineup with standard EDITION in-room amenities and several accessible room options.
Roxy pairs multiple in-house venues with nightly entertainment throughout the property.
Choose Roxy for integrated dining and live-music programming across several venues.
The New York EDITION features The Clocktower restaurant plus two bars/lounges and 24-hour room service.
Opt for EDITION for classic restaurant and lounge offerings with round-the-clock room service.
Roxy does not have an on-site swimming pool; its signature amenities are entertainment venues.
Roxy’s standout features are cultural and entertainment spaces rather than pool or beach amenities.
The supplier listing references spa treatment room(s) and spa services on site.
The EDITION provides on-site spa treatment options, but a pool is not documented in the supplied listing.
At Roxy the nightlife and entertainment program is part of the hotel experience; wellness is limited to fitness and salon services.
Go Roxy if nights out and on-site live entertainment matter more than a full-service spa.
The New York EDITION combines quieter evening spaces with spa treatment rooms and fitness facilities.
Pick EDITION for a quieter, service-oriented stay with spa access and traditional hotel nightlife.

Roxy — nightly live jazz, DJs, resident pianist programming and a subterranean jazz club (The Django).

The New York EDITION — 5-star design-forward public spaces, restaurant and bars, and on-site spa treatment rooms.

Roxy — multiple event spaces including an 8-story atrium, cinema and rooftop penthouse terrace across extensive square footage.

The New York EDITION — steps from Madison Square Park and the Flatiron area, convenient for midtown sightseeing.
Roxy — it centers on live music, DJs and an independent cinema; entertainment is part of the daily programming.
The New York EDITION lists spa treatment room(s) and on-site spa services; Roxy partners with a nearby thermal-bath venue and has an on-site salon but not a full spa.
No — both properties welcome guests of all ages (Roxy has a minimum check-in age of 21).
Roxy is on the SoHo/Tribeca border for downtown access; The New York EDITION is steps from Madison Square Park and the Flatiron/NoMad area.
Explore how Roxy Hotel New York stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·